Monday, February 14, 2011

Chapters 14, 15, & 17

The three components of the writing workshop discussed in these chapters (conferences, share time, and assessment) are probably the most confusing to me as a future teacher. I am not a very good talker, and I have a tendency to be very indecisive.

As I was reading about conferences, I was trying to imagine myself in Ray's role. She was talking about keeping conferences short, and I thought back to the many times a student has called me over to tell me a story and has kept going and going until some major event happened (the class was going to specials or lunch). I listen to the whole story intently (or at least I keep up the ruse that I am listening intently), even though I have other things I should be doing. It's not that I'm a complete pushover; I just don't like to hurt peoples' feelings. If I cut someone off in the middle of a story, I run the risk of hurting their feelings. That is not something I like to do. Also, I like to think that this story, however long winded it may be, is important to the student - otherwise, why would they be telling it to me? I don't want to dismiss something that is important to the student if I am trying to build a caring community in the classroom. I know this is something I need to work on - cutting a student off if they talk too much, especially during a writing conference.

Something else that made me think was the section when Ray was talking about getting a student to talk. I was that student. I was painfully shy (and still am under certain circumstances), and it really took a lot to get me talking about something. If I'm being honest, though, I still didn't divulge much no matter how much my teacher tried to get me to talk. I know there are other kids out there like that, so just how am I supposed to get them to tell me their thoughts on their own writing or what they're doing or anything else? The thing with me was I got self-conscious very easily. My teacher would ask me one "why" question (why did you choose that topic? why did you write it like that? why this, why that?), and I would clam up and question myself. Even if that teacher wasn't asking a why question to be critical, that's how I took it. I just generally did not enjoy conferencing with teachers, and I wonder how I could prevent that feeling in my future students.

Speaking of being a shy person, there is no way in heck that I would have ever shared anything with the class. If my teacher had made sharing mandatory, even if it was just one sentence, I would have dreaded it. So, while I found Ray's chapter on share time to be interesting, I have to say that I believe the best way to conduct share time is to invite students who want to up to the front to share a piece of their writing. Making sharing a mandatory thing will make writing workshop not fun for some students, and I believe writing workshop should be at least enjoyable if not fun.

Assessing a student's writing will be hard for me, because grading a piece of writing to me is more like a judgement call than anything. With a test, you can't feel guilty when you mark an answer wrong because there is a specific right answer you are looking for. With writing, there may be something specific you asked the students to write about or include in their writing, but everyone has different interpretations and different ways of getting a point across. A particular student's way of getting a point across might not mesh with my way of getting a point across, but does that mean I should give them a bad grade? Of course, it will not be hard to mark points off for incorrect spelling or grammar. I am just not looking forward to grading writing based on content or style. I would much rather give each student a sticker for their effort and move on.

1 comment:

  1. So, I'm sure you are hating me now for telling you that sharing is going to happen, like it or not, in a couple of weeks. To be sure, as a shy person myself, I do know what this means. This is especially important given that I've asked everyone to write about topics and experiences that are personally important and meaningful. This is one reason why I share, too, because I need to be reminded what I am asking of everyone.

    So, at the least, take a deep breath and try to get through it. You will be amazing, though. I have no doubt.

    You'll have students who hold back, no matter what. That is ok. As long as you are open and listening and encouraging, that is all you can do.

    Beth

    ReplyDelete