I found chapter 9 to be useful in the sense that it adds a little more to my classroom To Do list. As I get closer and closer to being an actual teacher, I find myself thinking of everything I will need to have an appropriately and nicely decorated classroom, as well as a well stocked one when it comes to literature. I am a huge Social Studies/History nerd, so my first thoughts obviously veer toward what kind of history books I will have in my class library. I never thought about having writing books available to my students, though it makes perfect sense. Providing students with little to no resources on a certain subject will deter them from ever really learning and understanding that subject. If a teacher, for example, simply tells her students to write every day and has no writing resource books, none of the students can be expected to learn a great deal. Writing does get better with practice, but using material resources like professional writing journals or grammar instructional books will enrich a student's writing even further.
Something else that stood out to me in chapter 9 was Ray's section of living in our classrooms. She mentions that students will be less inclined to learn something if their teacher acts - whether consciously or unconsciously - as if they have no interest in the subject. I can see how Ray is correct, as young children can be very impressionable, especially if they really admire a particular person. In my field placement on Thursday, I was cutting out strips of paper for a math center while sitting at an empty desk next to a female student. While I was cutting the paper, I experienced Deja Vu - the weirdest feeling ever. I asked the girl sitting next to me if she knew what Deja Vu was, then I told her I had just felt it. A few minutes later, the girl put her hand on her hand and said to me, "Oh wow. I feel like this has happened before... I remember someone sitting next to me cutting paper... I remember this." It was quite obvious the girl was not experiencing Deja Vu - you could tell by the way she was talking - but I went along with it. In fact, I was quite flattered. I felt as if the girl was trying to be like me. Since I had just told her I had Deja Vu, she wanted to have it, as well. Reading the section on demonstrating in Ray's book made me think of this event and realize how true Ray's point really is. I also thought about how there are certain subjects I really do not like (cough*math*cough*science*cough). It will be pretty hard for me to act interested in those subjects, but I will try my best. I won't be surprised, however, if my students can tell a difference between my genuine enthusiasm and my false enthusiasm.
I do not have much to say on chapter 10, but I would like to comment on one thing: Ray talks about teaching techniques and gives an example from a Gary Paulsen book. In the text, Paulsen writes, "It was going to be a long, loong night." I like the connection Ray makes to the children's books and to her own writing, but I would like to say that whenever I did anything of that sort in my writing, it was not well received. If I spelled a wrong incorrectly, like "loong," even if I was trying to make a point, I was told not to do it. So, while teaching children about these techniques could be useful, it may also be giving them false hope about being really creative with their writing. I love to use different methods of stating inflection (like using all capital letters when I'm REALLY excited about something, or using italics when I'm emphasizing something, or adding extra letters to words to show that I love something soooooooooo much). BUT, if I ever did something like that in a school writing assignment, it was not recognized as being "creative" or "expressive." I would like to change that, but I know not all teachers will. So, is it better to leave writing techniques like that alone?
Chapter 13 was very interesting and useful when it comes to teaching, not just writing, but any subject. Ray says that students feel more empowered to learn when their teacher is not just telling them what to do, but talks to them like one writer to another. I think that is a great approach to take in the general classroom. Treating young children with respect instead of talking down to them will make a world of difference in a learning environment. I am still in that stage of my student teaching where I become friends with my students, so they tend to see me as more of an ally against any kind of school authority than a teacher. While I will have to work on the boundaries of friendliness in the classroom, there is an advantage to it. The kids see me as a friend, they know I care about them, and they know I believe in them (if only because I tell them that often). I strongly believe in a caring, loving classroom - which will be no problem for me seeing as it's extremely rare for me to not care about a child I come in contact with. Also, the kids feel comfortable around me and know they can trust me. So, when I tell them they are smart and have to try their best to achieve something, they usually believe it.
Something else that caught my attention in chapter 13 was the mention of overalls. Does Ray really own a pair of overalls? This book was published 10 years ago, so I'll give her the benefit of the doubt and assume the overalls have been banished. I'll tell you right now, none of my future students will ever hear about my pair of overalls - because I will never own any.
Ha! on overalls.
ReplyDeleteYour point on the grammatical conventional correctness is well said. I tell my students to pick up any decent children's novel and read a couple of pages. I guarantee you there will be sentence fragments, put there intentionally for stylistic reasons. For me, that kind of stuff falls under the heading of "voice" or "style" and is a mark of sophistication, not a deficit. But it has to be intentional. The writer has to be able to talk about their choices. So I would take a passage with some clear "violations" and study it. Why did the author break these sentences up this way? Does it add meaning to the story?
You are right that not all teachers will feel this way. I can't solve that. I think my only defense is that overemphasis on conventions and grammar seems to suck the life out of student interest. However, I will say that students NEED to know the rules and that they must obey them when writing, for example, a letter to the editor of the local newspaper. So, the child needs to know the rules, how they work, and when it is appropriate to break them.
Beth