Just as I was very interested in learning how to best incorporate reading in the classroom last semester, I am very excited to learn the ways and benefits of having a specific time set aside solely for writing. I am an avid reader, and I most definitely plan to turn my students into avid readers, as well (do I believe I will be 100% successful every year? Of course not. But a girl can dream!). Because I am an avid reader, I do feel a special connection to writing. A person obviously has to write a book in order for me to read it; therefore, if I had a negative feeling toward writing, it would not make much sense. The first five chapters in Ray's book helped set the stage for conducting a writing workshop in the classroom. I learned many new concepts and ideas, but some of my own ideas about writing in the classroom were confirmed (and even denied!).
I found the section about the tone of the classroom/writing workshop to be very useful and instructive. I have, of course, thought about the feeling of a particular classroom. I have been in many different classrooms before, and they have all had a different feeling to them. A classroom's feeling or tone has a lot to do with the posters/projects on the wall, the set up of the desks and other furniture, whether or not there are rugs, pillows, or comfy chairs, how well organized the class is, and many other factors. For example, I have a cousin who is a third grade teacher in Gwinnett county. I have visited her classroom many, many times. Maybe it just because I know her, but I also feel very welcome in her room. She has cute, school-related posters up, pillows around the very organized class library, pictures of her family on her desk, bright and colorful decorations on the bulletin boards, and the students' desks set up in small groups. My mentor teacher's classroom, however, is not as welcoming. As I have only visited this particular classroom twice, I will not make any judgments or inferences. I will only state what I have observed, which is the following: the desks are set up in rows, there are papers and books strewn about on spare desks, tables, and even the floor, the class library is overflowing from the small bookshelves, and all the decorations and posters are crowded out by overstuffed cabinets. I do not know if the room is a deterrent to the students, but I have a hard time concentrating in that classroom (and I have only been there for two days!).
Anyways... The point I was getting to was I had never thought about a particular lesson having a tone. I guess it makes sense because the way a teacher talks to and interacts with her students is a huge factor in how she is perceived - a kind, encouraging teacher will usually be remembered by her students as a good teacher, while a more stern teacher who does not interact very much with her students will be remembered - most likely - as a bad teacher. When I think back on teachers who I thought were "bad," I can only remember something mean or discouraging they said to me. I am sure, however, that there was at least one lesson they taught that I enjoyed. Obviously, not every lesson will have an excellent tone - I can just imagine what future lessons of mine will not have the most encouraging tone and which lessons definitely will. But, now that I know about the tone of a lesson and not just the classroom, I can consciously think of what I am doing well or not well during a lesson.
The other section of these first five chapters I enjoyed reading was the section about integrating and the types of writing. The past couple of semesters, we have talked about integrating the curriculum as a great way to break up the monotony of a routine. Most of the time, the curriculum in question is integrated with writing, since it is by far the easiest subject that connects with all the other subjects. A student can write about a book they've read, an informational paragraph about a historical event, a prediction they make about a science experiment, and more. Before reading I had no qualms with the idea of integrating writing throughout the curriculum. After reading my feelings have not changed, but I do understand Ray's point about writing curriculum being overlooked because of all the integration. That is definitely something I will have to consider when planning my curriculum - I do believe a child needs as much practice as he or she can get when it comes to writing, but he or she also needs to learn the ins and outs of writing well.
I appreciate your balanced approach to Ray and her thoughts on integration. I should have said today in class that Ray can be a bit extreme for me in some cases, and this is one issue where I differ with her. I do think you can honor the principles of the workshop while writing to other areas of the curriculum. But, as you skillfully say, it is easy for writing to get slighted.
ReplyDeleteYour point about the connection between readers and writers is well said. Certainly, taking a new eye to what we read can only add to our skills as writers. Excellent post! Looking forward to the next.